New Sportsgrounds for Chatswood West?

Most people would be aware that the sports fields in Willoughby are reaching their capacity. Some of the time fields are unplayable due to adverse weather. At other times, there are different sporting codes vying for the same space or timeslot. There is not just a need across
the city for more sporting grounds. Chatswood, West Ward contains six schools, all are growing in student numbers and they have an increasing demand for sporting facilities.

There is a limited number of strategies that can be used to address this situation. Installing synthetic surfaces on existing fields can overcome some of the adverse weather situations. The implementation of lighting on fields can extend the playing time on a particular field. Working out how to facilitate multiple sporting codes on the same surface can address some of the time slot issues. The final approach is to find spaces for new fields. This latter approach can be prohibitively expensive (due to the high value of land in the city.

Twenty years ago, Council proposed to install lights and a synthetic surface on the O.H. Reid Oval site. The local residents object, mainly due to the topography of the area. The idea was shelved. More recently, Council has been undertaking a review of all its sporting facilities. Whilst solutions have been found for some sports that only require relatively small areas, finding locations for new sporting oval has not been successful.

A local Chatswood West resident has come up with an innovative (albeit likely contentious) solution. His idea is to build ovals at the northern end of Chatswood Golf Club. Possibly 2 to 3 sporting fields could be located on public land currently leased to the golf club (the lease is currently up for renewal). He points out that the site is well-serviced by buses along Delhi Rd. There is an existing unformed vehicular road into the area where parking could be located without cars having to go by residential streets.

The downside for this proposal is the impact on the Golf Club. Currently, three of the club’s eighteen holes are located on the public land leased from Council. The proposal would reduce the course to fifteen holes. This would mean golfers would have to play three holes twice. Whilst the proposal to reclaim the public land for more diverse is radical, it does awaken some issues worthy of consideration. It would be quite interesting to see the number of players per year that use our various sporting facilities. Particularly if this is analysed by the size of the facility and the return to Council from fee or leases.

.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “New Sportsgrounds for Chatswood West?

  1. There are more considerations at play here than might first meet the eye.

    1. It’s a working golf course patronised by thousands every week. What about their amenity?
    2. The area in question is a narrow river flood plain made up of unconsolidated tertiary gravel constrained in a steep sandstone valley and the lot of it is subject to innundation in heavy rain events.
    3. The relict mangroves growing along the river would almost certainly be either destroyed or significantly degraded in the geological works that would be required to stabilise the area such that full sized playing fields would fit between the river and Reid Drive.
    4.This isn’t a case of taking out the flags and holes and simply replacing them with goal posts and white lines. This project, were it to go ahead, would require significant hydrological and geological surveys, large earthworks and reduction or removal of large volumes of the sandstone that forms the valley sides at lower levels.
    5. Such works would surely interfere with the amenity of residents in Reid Drive, The Fairway, Valerie Avenue and the lower Fullers Road/Millwood Avenue precinct and this disruption would continue throughout the construction phase; to be followed by regular traffic disruption on play days that could only add to the already significant traffic congestion common in the area.

    While I agree there is an urgent need for additional sports fields in the municipality I think that the idea of turning the area in question into playing fields is a non starter.

  2. I absolutely concur with Rob duRose. The golf course is a little gem, quietly enjoyed by many thousands. It is one of only two 18 hole golf courses on the lower North Shore, with three others being 9 hole courses. Removal of the 3 holes on leased land would destroy its viability.What could follow does not bear thinking about.

    The course itself is a valuable adjunct to the protection of the river frontage, as it is responsibly maintained by the club. It is both an environmental and aesthetic asset to the neighbourhood which must not be put at risk.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s