Phone TowerOver 60 people recently attended a meeting called by Visionstream and Optus at the Chatswood Golf Club.

As outlined in an earlier post, Optus is proposing to install a 30 or 32 M Telecommunications tower on Golf Course land. The proposed site is in the middle of the Club’s car park and will impact on many nearby residents.

Optus has engaged Visionstream to undertake community consultation. They had only notified 24 households (mainly in Colwell Crescent). The notification letter was in a nondescript envelope delivered during the holiday period.

The Clubhouse was packed with local residents. There was a smattering (6) of Optus/Visionstream staffers on hand . On questioning, Visionstream said their intention was to have ‘one-on-one’ sessions with residents to answer question.

This is a typical community consultant’s strategy to ‘divide and conquer’ residents .

It was pointed out to Visionstream that it was rather difficult to ask a question when nobody really knew what was being proposed. However, Visionstream persisted that they were there to answer questions in a one on one situation.

Former Councillor Terry Fogarty, now of the Chatswood West Ward Progress Association, addressed the throng and confirmed that the community’s expectation was to have a presentation from Optus/Visionstream. This was very reluctantly agreed to.

Optus outlined the proposed location of the tower in the golf course carpark. The first issue canvassed related to what alternative sites had been considered. This included St Peter’s Green which was rejected as the owners did not consent to the proposal. This site was also rejected because of concern for elderly residents. The Visionstream representative commented that places such as aged care are considered community sensitive. It was stated that alternative sites on both the course and the local area were considered but rejected. This was primarily for technical reasons but also because the land owners did not consent to the proposal. The location of other Optus towers were also discussed as telecommunications providers are required to consider co-localisation with other facilities prior to the installation of a new site. Other sites mentioned included existing sites in far-away Artarmon, the Chatswood Tennis club and sites in the commercial zone at the bottom of Mowbray Road. So it is obvious there are many alternative sites outside of Chatswood Golf Club that could be chosen. The resident’s view is that the Golf Club site was selected because it is the lowest cost option. In addition, the Golf Club has provided consent to Optus for the installation of the proposed facility and entered in to a lease agreement. At the meeting no alternative sites on the golf course were discussed and questions relating to this were deflected by Visionsteam and Optus and answers evasive.

The Golf Club President addressed the meeting. He claimed that the Club is  in a dire financial position and that if the deal didn’t go ahead it may be forced to close (it would be interesting to analyse the Golf Club’s financial accounts ). The President also said that if they sold their land it is likely the outcome would probably be the construction of multi-storey units on the land. Any development on the land in the event that the Club was required to be sold would need to be approved by Willoughby Council. Land adjacent to the Club along Colwell Crescent is currently zoned as 2A Scenic Protection and E4 Environmental Living. The Golf Club owns most of the site (except for a small potion leased from Willoughby Council near the Fullers Bridge).

The proposed tower will co-host Vodafone antennas. If Telstra wanted to use the tower they would need to sign contracts with Optus and the Golf Club.

There will be a DA lodged with Willoughby Council. Optus stated that Council is the determining consent authority.

The information provided on three panels for the session included a design sketch of the tower and location, pictures of the proposed tower superimposed onto the carpark and behind a house in Colwell Crescent and a ‘location map’ of other Optus sites in the area. The information was not yet available on the a web site (rfnsa.com.au/2067030). However,  Visonstream and Optus representatives promised to advise people who left their email address when information would be available on the web.

Residents were unhappy with the timing of the meeting (between 4 pm and 6 pm on a weekday afternoon) Visionstream and Optus agreed to hold another meeting outside of business hours before the DA is lodged.



  1. Thanks so much to everyone who has supported the community cause of ‘No Tower for the Chatswood Golf Club’.

    We had over 60 people at the meeting with Optus & VisionStream last Thursday night and the collective community made it clear that we will not allow this tower to go ahead in the proposed location and we are not satisfied with the level of community consultation or alternative site consideration.

    What we know:

    We have gathered a tremendous amount of information to date. Here is a summary:
    The proposed location for the tower is approx. 10m off the back fence of No. 21 Colwell Crescent.

    The plot of land is privately owned by Chatswood Golf Club and Optus entered into a lease of some sort with the Club several years ago.

    The Club’s financial statements lodged with ASIC show they are in significant financial difficulty (in excess of $800k), yet the rent from the land leased to Optus will deliver only $21,000 per annum which will do little to alleviate the debt. The income from leasing the land for the tower is not the fix to the Club’s financial problems the President led the community to believe at the public meeting. It is highly possible the Club could fold regardless and leave a legacy of a 30m tower.

    An approved Development Application is required from Council in order for the Tower to go ahead.

    A few other sites were considered, but those site considerations were not thorough and very few in number.

    Very few Club members are aware of what the Club has proposed to do to their local community.

    In short, this is an ill considered plan where our local Club has prioritized an ill considered solution under the ruse to keep themselves afloat which appears untrue, yet impose a 30m tower over the community that supports them. There are many successfully run golf clubs in Sydney that have not resorted to these measures, so it is up to the community to make clear to all parties that this is not a satisfactory solution.

    What next?
    We are hopeful we can negotiate with Optus / Visionstream and Chatswood Golf Club for a more equitable and suitable outcome that is amenable to all. We have been contacted and promised that meetings will be scheduled to commence these discussions. However, this is not a forgone conclusion so its key to our success that we continue to let people know that the current proposal is unsatisfactory.

    With the tremendous amount of support that has been forthcoming, and whilst we organize all the data received and collect more, where you can be of most help is as follows:

    If you are a member of Chatswood Golf Club, make it known to your President that this is not a satisfactory solution.

    Write to Gladys Berejiklian and seek her support – despite how she might initially reply, this is a local issue and not a matter for our Federal member Joe Hockey.

    Make as many people in our community aware of this issue and ask them to like and follow the facebook page http://www.facebook.com/notowerchatswood

    Put a sign in your front, back or side yard to make your views known. Email notowerchatswood@gmail.com requesting one and we will have it printed and delivered to your house.

    Let us know what skills you have (legal, communications, PR, pamphlet delivery?), or contacts or relationships that may be of use to help as we progress. When specific needs arise, we’ll email and update the facebook page.

    We will continue to send emails fortnightly or when significant events occur, as well as update the facebook page. Please also regularly refer to the West Ward website – http://www.cwwpa.org – a story has been placed on the website regarding our concerns.

    Please keep in touch and if you have ideas or would like to be part of the immediate action group that will likely meet weekly, let us know.

    Thanks to everyone. We will succeed as long as we fight this as a community and keep up the momentum.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s