Asbestos – Chatswood High School Oval

AsbestosAccording to Clr. Saville, Asbestos has been found in the Chatswood High School (CHS) oval fill. Over many years, fill has been used to maintain the oval, & at times the oval has been dug up & drainage attended. I am not aware if any soil (or fill) testing was done during these activities.

A synthetic grass oval was to be installed with funds allocated from the Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) with developer Meriton, negotiated by council. Fill sampling has revealed the presence of asbestos fibres.

Additional costs for safe asbestos removal are beyond the funds allocated from the VPA, and this project has been placed on hold. Council will approach the local member, Ms Gladys Berejiklian for funding to meet the extra costs.

The following questions must be raised:

a) was any sampling was undertaken previously?
b) is the asbestos throughout the fill or is it in locations that can be isolated from current use?
c) can the asbestos be stabilised or consolidated to prevent dispersal and/or fibres becoming airborn as soon as possible?
d) how safe is the oval for use with or without the synthetic grass cover?

The DET has built a new primary school adjacent to the oval, I am concerned that asbestos is a health hazard, and that young people, being closer to the ground, and in close proximity, are particularly exposured.

Lynne Saville

Amalgamations Update

FitForTheFutureIn October 2013 the Independent Local Government Review Panel released its final report ‘Revitalising Local Government’. The report made 65 recommendations including proposed mergers between metropolitan councils in Sydney. As part of these recommendations the Panel‟s preferred option for Willoughby is to amalgamate with neighbouring councils Lane Cove, North Sydney, Mosman, Hunters Hill and part of Ryde.

In October 2014 the Office of Local Government released the Fit for the Future framework which denotes the following characteristics for a council to be „Fit for the Future‟:

Has the scale and capacity to engage effectively across community, industry and government
Financially Sustainable
Effectively manages infrastructure and delivers services for communities

At the recent Northern Sydney Councils’ Fit for the Future Symposium, held on 5 February at The Concourse Civic Pavilion, it was noted that addressing „Scale and capacity is the first hurdle in Fit for the Future documents, financial sustainability is subordinate‟ and that „Under Fit for the Future, a council is deemed to have scale and capacity if the Panel‟s recommended amalgamation configuration is adopted. No justification is provided by government, or required from the councils that are to merge‟. The option of forming Joint Organisations is available to rural councils, however this option has not been extended to metropolitan councils.

Further, at the Fit for the Future Symposium it was evident that while some councils have resolved to either accept or reject the proposed amalgamations, others, including Willoughby, are yet to make a decision on their position. The key point made at the Symposium was that „The Government‟s objective is that there are amalgamations in Metropolitan Sydney to significantly reduce the number of councils‟.

At this stage other councils in the Northern Region have declared the following positions on the issue of amalgamation

Hunters Hill: Position to be confirmed at Council meeting within the next month.

Lane Cove: Resolved to oppose forced amalgamations on 21 January 2015 Extraordinary Meeting of Council.

Mosman: Mayoral Minute 4 June 2013 opposing forced amalgamation.

North Sydney: North Sydney Council‟s current position is that; „Council has affirmed it is fit for the future as a stand-alone council, but has agreed to hold discussions with neighbouring councils and to explore other options. A public meeting is to be held on 23 February to discuss options.

Ryde: Extraordinary General Meeting held Tuesday 17 February, Ryde – at the time of preparing this report – proposed to reaffirm its objection to forced amalgamations.

Hornsby: At 12 November 2014 meeting Council resolved to „undertake discussions with our neighbouring councils regarding the possibility of merging with one or a number of those councils to create a new entity which meets the Scale and Capacity requirements of the Government.‟
A further report is to be prepared in early 2015.

Ku-Ring-Gai: 25 June 2013 Council resolved: A. That Council not proceed with discussions on amalgamation as the disadvantages for Ku-ring-gai residents far outweigh any perceived advantages. B. That we encourage and participate with NSROC in investigating opportunities to increase the range of resource and services sharing.

Willoughby Council, will need to decide if it will prepare a Council Improvement Proposal making an argument that Council has the scale and capacity to stand alone (known as template 2) or a Council Merger Proposal (known as template 1).

It is therefore suggested that Councillors hold a workshop to clarify the options and to ascertain a preferred position. This workshop is scheduled for the first week in March and forms part of the attached timelines.

Traffic Update

RMSAt its February meeting the Willoughby Traffic Committee considered a number of items pertinent to West Ward.

Anderson St & Victoria Avenue: Problems with cars blocking intersection and conflict between cars and pedestrians. Resolved: RMS asked to carry out Safety Audit.

Mowbray Rd West, east of Felton: Pedestrian refuge does not meet current standards. Resolved: Refuge to be upgraded.

Archer & Victoria: Pedestrian countdown timers have produced positive responses. Resolved: Request to RMS to leave timers in place and to install timers at additional locations.

Hatfield St, Lane Cove North and Mowbray Rd West: Mowbray School has requested installation of temporary pedestrian crossings. Resolved: Temporary crossings to be installed.

In addition, various works have been approved in Lone Pine Avenue to resolve problems with bus movements;

Read Full Report